7 ways to spot an insincere person, according to psychology

We all treasure honesty, right? I mean, who wants to be around people who can’t be sincere? Yet, spotting an insincere person isn’t always as easy as we wish it would be.

Here’s the deal.

Psychology has given us some valuable insights into this. It has outlined certain behaviors and traits that are typical of individuals who aren’t really ‘playing straight’.

So, if you’re wondering “How can I tell if someone isn’t being sincere?” keep reading.

This article will cover the 7 ways, backed by psychology, to identify insincerity in a person.

Remember, it’s not about being judgmental. It’s about understanding human behavior better and making informed decisions about the relationships we want to nurture in our lives.

Who knows? You may even uncover some surprising truths about the people around you. Or better yet, learn something new about yourself.

Intrigued? Let’s dive in!

1) Inconsistency in their words and actions

We’ve all heard it before, right? Actions speak louder than words. Well, psychology backs this up.

When you’re trying to spot an insincere person, look out for inconsistencies between what they say and what they actually do.

For instance, someone who promises to always be there for you but is consistently absent when you need them? That’s a classic sign of insincerity.

But remember, we’re all human. We all make mistakes and sometimes fail to keep our word. What we’re focusing on here are patterns of behavior.

So, if you notice a recurring discrepancy between a person’s words and actions, it might be a red flag that they aren’t as sincere as they claim to be.

2) Overly flattering and insincere compliments

We all love a good compliment, right? But there’s a difference between genuine praise and flattery that feels a bit… off.

I remember, I had this friend back in college. Let’s call her Jenny. Jenny was always quick to shower everyone with praises. At first, it felt nice. Who doesn’t like being complimented, right?

But soon, I started noticing something. Her compliments were often exaggerated and didn’t quite match the situation. If I simply tied my hair up, she would gush about how I looked like a Hollywood star.

It felt insincere, like she was just saying things to win favor or get something in return. And psychology agrees.

Over-the-top, insincere compliments can be a sign of an insincere person. They use flattery as a tool to manipulate others or to hide their real intentions.

So next time someone lays it on thick with the compliments, take a moment to assess whether they’re being genuine or just trying to butter you up for some reason.

3) Lack of genuine interest

Ever been in a conversation where it feels like the other person is just waiting for their turn to speak? Like they’re more interested in hearing their own voice than actually listening to what you’re saying?

I think we’ve all been there. And let me tell you, it’s not a pleasant feeling.

Psychology tells us that a genuine person will show genuine interest. They’ll actively listen, respond thoughtfully, and engage with you on a deeper level.

On the flip side, an insincere person might seem distracted or disinterested. They might constantly check their phone during your conversation, or their responses might feel shallow and disconnected.

So, keep an eye out for this behavior. If someone doesn’t show genuine interest in what you’re saying, chances are they might not be as sincere as they seem.

4) They’re always playing the victim

Have you ever noticed how some people seem to always be at the center of drama? Nothing is ever their fault, and they always seem to be the victim.

It’s like they have a never-ending supply of sad stories and tales of woe to share. And while it’s natural to empathize with them at first, over time you might start questioning the authenticity of these stories.

According to psychology, consistently playing the victim could be a sign of insincerity.

You see, by painting themselves as the perpetual victim, these individuals manipulate others into sympathizing with them. 

It’s a way for them to avoid taking responsibility and to keep the spotlight firmly on themselves.

5) They’re quick to break confidences

Confidentiality is the cornerstone of trust in any relationship. When we share our secrets with someone, we’re showing them that we trust them.

But what happens when that trust is broken?

Interestingly, researchers at the University of California found that people are more likely to share secrets with others if they believe those secrets will enhance their social standing.

Now, think about it. If someone is quick to spill your secrets or share confidential information about others with you, what does that say about their sincerity?

A person who is sincere values trust and respects confidentiality. 

But an insincere person? They might use these shared secrets as currency for their own gain.

6) They rarely show empathy

Empathy, the ability to understand and share the feelings of others, is a critical aspect of sincere relationships. It’s what connects us on a deeper, more meaningful level.

Let’s think about a situation where you’re going through a tough time. A sincere friend will try to understand your feelings, offer comfort, and stand by your side.

But an insincere person? They might dismiss your feelings or even use them against you. Not out of malice, but because they struggle with genuine empathy.

Remember, spotting an insincere person isn’t about labeling or judging them. It’s about protecting your emotional well-being and cultivating relationships that are rooted in sincerity and respect.

So, if someone consistently lacks empathy, it might be time to reconsider their place in your life.

7) They often mirror your behavior

This one might surprise you.

Mirroring, or mimicking another person’s behavior, is a common social bonding tactic. However, when it’s excessive and insincere, it’s a different story.

If you notice someone constantly mirroring your likes, dislikes, opinions, or even your body language, it could be a sign of insincerity.

They might be trying to create a false sense of familiarity or likability to manipulate your perception of them.

So remember, authenticity is key. Genuine people are comfortable being themselves. They don’t need to mirror others to fit in or be liked.

Wrapping it up

So there you have it. These are the key signs to look out for when trying to spot an insincere person.

Remember, this isn’t about judging people or labeling them as ‘bad’. 

It’s about understanding human behavior better, protecting our emotional well-being, and fostering genuine, sincere relationships.

If you’ve recognized some of these traits in people around you, don’t jump to conclusions. 

Observe, reflect and trust your intuition. After all, intuition is a powerful tool that often leads us in the right direction.

And if you’ve noticed these traits within yourself, remember it’s never too late for self-improvement. 

Authenticity is a journey, not a destination.

So let’s embrace this journey with open minds and hearts. Let’s strive for more sincerity and authenticity in our interactions. 

Because at the end of the day, being true to ourselves and others is what truly matters.

Take a moment to reflect on this and remember – sincerity starts with ourselves.

Isabella Chase

Isabella Chase, a New York City native, writes about the complexities of modern life and relationships. Her articles draw from her experiences navigating the vibrant and diverse social landscape of the city. Isabella’s insights are about finding harmony in the chaos and building strong, authentic connections in a fast-paced world.

Women who are intimidating on the surface but kind underneath usually display these 7 behaviors

Men who are profoundly unhappy in life usually display these 8 specific behaviors (without realizing it)