7 subtle signs someone’s generosity isn’t sincere (and you shouldn’t accept it)

We sometimes include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Read our affiliate disclosure.

We all appreciate a generous act, don’t we?

But sometimes, you can’t help but wonder… is this person really being sincere? Or are they just trying to win me over for their own gain?

The sad truth is, not all acts of generosity are genuine. Some people use them as a tool for manipulation, to get what they want.

If you’ve ever been on the receiving end of such ‘generosity’, you’ll know it can leave a sour taste in your mouth.

And let’s be honest, none of us want that.

So today, let’s delve into 7 subtle signs that someone’s generosity isn’t as sincere as it seems.

1) They make sure everyone knows about their generosity

Ever been around someone who likes to broadcast their good deeds? I have.

I once had a friend who would donate to charity regularly, which is a wonderful thing. But then, he’d make sure to mention it in every conversation, to everybody he met.

It got to the point where it felt less like he was doing it because he genuinely cared, and more like he was doing it for the recognition and praise.

This is a classic sign that someone’s generosity might not be sincere.

2) They use their kindness to manipulate

Now this one really gets to me.

I remember a time when I was working on a project with a colleague. She would always offer to take on the bulk of the work, insisting that I should take it easy.

Initially, I thought she was just being kind. But as time went on, I realized that she was using her ‘generosity’ as leverage.

Whenever we had a disagreement, she’d remind me of all the times she’d done most of the work and insist that I should agree with her because of it.

That’s when I realized that her generosity wasn’t genuine, but a tool for manipulation.

3) They expect something in return

In the world of business, there’s an old saying – “There’s no such thing as a free lunch”. This implies that if someone is giving you something, they often expect something in return.

So, picture this: you notice someone going all out with their generosity, but at the same time, they’re dropping hints about expecting something in return. It’s like a little alarm going off, making you wonder if their motives are as pure as they first seemed.

The thing is – genuine kindness is about helping out without any strings attached.

This whole scenario screams of a give-and-take strategy, where their initial friendliness is just a tactic to line up future favors or special treatment.  

4) Their generosity is inconsistent

Generosity, when it’s sincere, comes from the heart. It’s consistent, not selective. But what if it’s not?

Imagine having a friend who is extremely generous towards you in public, but in private, the generosity is nowhere to be seen. It feels wrong, doesn’t it?

That’s because true generosity isn’t dependent on circumstances or audience. It’s an extension of one’s nature.

So remember, if someone’s generous actions are inconsistent, it might be a sign that their generosity isn’t sincere.

5) They hold their generosity over your head

I’ll never forget the time when I was fresh out of college and struggling to make ends meet.

A close relative offered to lend me some money to help me get on my feet. I was grateful for the help, but soon, it became a source of constant tension.

Every family gathering, every conversation, it seemed like they found a way to remind me of the ‘favor’ they had done. It felt like they held it over my head, using it as a way to control our relationship.

True generosity should never come with strings attached. If someone keeps reminding you of their act of kindness, it might be a sign that their generosity isn’t sincere.

6) They only give when it’s convenient for them

We all have that one friend or relative who seems to be generous only when it suits them. I remember a colleague who would only offer help when he had finished all his work and had spare time on his hands.

Here’s the thing: true generosity isn’t dictated by convenience. When someone’s generosity is tied to their schedule or mood, it’s likely that it’s not coming from a place of sincerity but rather from a place of self-interest.

7) They use generosity as a power play

In an influential study conducted by Professor Russell W. Belk, it was found that gifts are often used as a form of power play. The act of giving, especially when it is significant or frequent, can create a sense of obligation and power imbalance.

I’ve seen this play out firsthand in a previous job where my boss would frequently give gifts or bonuses to us, but then use these gifts to assert control and demand more work.

It’s important to remember that genuine generosity doesn’t come with a hidden agenda. If someone uses their acts of giving to gain power or control over you, it’s a clear sign that their generosity isn’t the real deal.

True generosity is unconditional

True generosity is a sincere exchange that uplifts both parties; anything less is a disservice to the essence of genuine connection.

So, as you navigate the complex web of human interactions, let sincerity be the compass guiding your choices.

Being aware of these signs can help you navigate relationships and situations more effectively. Remember, genuine kindness and generosity don’t come with expectations, strings attached, or ulterior motives. If you recognize these signs, don’t be afraid to set boundaries when necessary.  

Isabella Chase

Isabella Chase, a New York City native, writes about the complexities of modern life and relationships. Her articles draw from her experiences navigating the vibrant and diverse social landscape of the city. Isabella’s insights are about finding harmony in the chaos and building strong, authentic connections in a fast-paced world.

If someone makes you feel bad about these 7 things, they’re not worth keeping in your life

If you notice these 9 behaviors, you’re dealing with an emotionally immature and self-centered person