7 subtle signs a woman is being plastic with you, according to psychologists

Genuine connections are built on authenticity, but sometimes, interactions can feel insincere or “plastic.”

A woman being “plastic” with you may display subtle behaviors that suggest her friendliness isn’t genuine or that she’s masking her true feelings.

Spotting these subtle signs is a skill, a skill that psychologists have mastered; these experts can share some insights on how to tell if a woman is being plastic with you.

Here are seven subtle signs a woman is being plastic with you, as explained by psychologists.

1) She has an inconsistent behavior

There’s an element of predictability in genuine interactions.

People are creatures of habit, and this extends to how we interact with others, but when a woman is being ‘plastic’, her behavior might be inconsistent.

It’s as though they’re switching characters, adapting to what they think you want to see.

Consider this: One day she’s warm and friendly, the next day she’s distant and aloof or, perhaps, she acts differently in front of different people.

This inconsistency can be confusing, but remember, it’s a reflection on her, not you.

Always approach this observation with understanding and compassion.

It’s not always easy to be genuine, especially when we’re navigating complex social situations.

2) Her compliments don’t feel right

We all appreciate a good compliment as it can brighten our day and boost our confidence.

But have you ever received a compliment that just didn’t feel right?

I remember a certain interaction with a woman, let’s call her Jane: Jane had this habit of doling out compliments like candy.

At first, it seemed like she was just really nice, but over time, something felt off.

Every compliment felt surface level, lacking depth or connection to reality; it was as though she was saying things merely because they sounded nice, not because she meant them.

Psychologists confirm that, with ‘plasticity,’ the compliments are often generic or overly effusive, lacking sincerity.

It’s worth noting that it’s not about dismissing all compliments, but rather being aware of the intent behind them.

Genuine compliments usually come from a place of authenticity and connection—they feel real because they are real.

3) She’s listening, but not hearing

When people engage in conversation, there’s an expectation of mutual understanding.

You speak, they listen, and vice versa—but with someone who’s being ‘plastic’, they might listen but not truly hear you.

This phenomenon is backed by psychological research as studies show that people who are being insincere often fail to retain information from the conversations they have.

It’s as if they’re present physically, but mentally somewhere else.

This could manifest as them forgetting important details you’ve shared or consistently steering the conversation back to themselves.

Connections—that are genuine—are built on mutual understanding and active listening, not just empty nods and rehearsed responses.

4) The focus is always on herself

Ever had a conversation that feels more like a monologue? You’re not alone.

When a woman is being ‘plastic’, the spotlight is often centered on them.

They tend to dominate conversations, steering the topics back to themselves.

It’s not just about hogging the limelight as they might also consistently downplay your achievements while exaggerating their own, or show lack of interest in your stories.

A balanced conversation is a two-way street as it requires active interest and participation from both parties.

If you find that she’s making everything about her, it might be a subtle sign she’s being plastic with you.

5) Her lack of empathy

Empathy, the ability to understand and share the feelings of others, is a key component of genuine relationships.

I once confided in a woman about a personal struggle I was going through: Instead of offering comfort or understanding, she brushed it off, quickly changing the topic to something trivial and unrelated.

That was a red flag—empathy requires authenticity.

It’s about connecting on a deeper level and showing care for the other person’s feelings.

6) She’s overly agreeable

While it’s great to find common ground with someone, being overly agreeable can sometimes be a subtle sign of a ‘plastic’ personality.

It’s normal and healthy to have differing opinions.

After all, it’s our individual perspectives that make us unique.

However, if she always agrees with everything you say, it might be an attempt to appear likable rather than expressing her true feelings or thoughts.

Should she never voice a different viewpoint or challenge anything you say, you might want to question the sincerity behind her agreement.

7) Trust your gut

Above all, trust your instincts.

Subconscious cues can often alert us to insincerity before we consciously acknowledge it.

If something feels off, it might be because it is; your intuition can be a powerful tool in discerning between genuine and ‘plastic’ interactions.

Psychologists affirm the importance of trusting your gut feeling because it’s our brain’s way of processing information faster than our conscious mind can comprehend.

It might just be telling you that the woman you’re interacting with isn’t as genuine as she appears.

Final thoughts: It’s about authenticity

The dance of human interaction is delicate and complex, often leaving us to navigate a maze of emotions and intentions.

Encountering ‘plastic’ behavior can be unsettling, but it reflects their struggles, not your worth.

That being said, observation and intuition can guide you toward authentic connections.

We should all learn to extend empathy as everyone is navigating their own path—life is too short for surface-level ties.

Cherish those who show their true selves, flaws and all, because authenticity is priceless.