7 signs someone is deeply in love with you but trying to play it cool

There’s a fine line between someone showing genuine interest in you and someone trying to play it cool.

This line, often blurred by mixed signals, can leave us wondering if the person we’re interested in feels the same way.

When someone is deeply in love but trying to play it cool, they’ll drop subtle signs that can easily be missed. But when you know what to look for, these signs become clear as day.

In this article, I will guide you through the 7 signs someone is deeply in love with you but trying to play it cool.

So get ready to become a pro at reading between the lines!

1) They’re always around, but not too close

One of the key signs that someone is in love with you, but is trying to keep it low-key, is their consistent presence in your life.

This doesn’t mean they’re always in your face or constantly trying to grab your attention. Instead, they find subtle ways to be around you without being overwhelming.

They might frequent the same places as you or show up at events where they know you’ll be. They’re always there for you, but never in a way that feels intrusive.

This delicate balance between presence and distance is their way of staying connected, without revealing their true feelings. It’s their own unique way of playing it cool while keeping you within their sight.

The key?

Consistency. Everyone can have coincidental encounters, but if they’re consistently around – that’s a sign they might just be deeply in love with you.

2) They remember the little things

Another telltale sign that someone is deeply in love but playing it cool is their knack for remembering the little things.

I remember when I was in this exact situation, there was this person who always seemed to remember the tiniest details about me.

They’d recall a random fact that I had mentioned casually, or they’d know my favorite coffee order despite me never explicitly telling them.

At first, I thought it was just a coincidence, but then I realized it was their way of showing they cared. They were paying attention to me, and not just what I said, but how I felt and what I valued.

So if someone in your life seems to have an uncanny memory when it comes to you – from your likes and dislikes to your dreams and fears – there’s a good chance they’re in love with you but are trying to keep it under wraps.

3) They act differently around you

Have you ever noticed someone’s demeanor shift when you enter the room? They might become more animated, quieter, or even a bit awkward. 

Science supports this: studies have shown that when we’re attracted to someone, our body language and behavior may change subconsciously. We might mimic the other person’s actions or become more self-conscious of our own.

So if you’ve observed a shift in their behavior when they’re around you – whether it’s them becoming more talkative or unusually quiet – it could be because they’re trying to suppress their feelings for you.

This subtle change is a clear sign they’re trying to keep their cool while being deeply in love with you.

4) They’re protective of you

When someone is deeply in love, they can’t help but feel a certain level of protectiveness towards the person they care about.

This doesn’t mean they’re going to act like your personal bodyguard, but they will subtly step up if they feel you’re in any kind of discomfort or danger.

Perhaps they offer to walk you home late at night, or they express concern if you’re hanging out with someone they don’t trust. They might even get mildly upset if they see you being treated unfairly.

All these actions indicate that they value your safety and well-being. They love you and want to ensure you’re okay, but they’re also trying to play it cool, so their protectiveness comes out in subtle ways.

It’s another sign that they are deeply in love with you.

5) They share their world with you

When someone opens up their world to you, it’s a clear sign of trust and affection. And in my experience, it’s often a sign of deep, underlying love.

I recall a time when someone I knew started inviting me to meet their friends and family. They shared their favorite books with me and even took me to the spots they loved the most in the city.

Initially, I didn’t think much of it. But looking back now, I realize that they were subtly trying to intertwine our lives.

They were in love with me, but they were playing it cool by sharing their life with me bit by bit.

So if someone starts sharing more of their world with you – their dreams, their fears, their people – consider it a sign. 

6) They’re always there when you need them

One of the most significant signs that someone is deeply in love with you is their reliability. They are the person you can count on, no matter what the situation is.

Whether it’s a flat tire in the middle of nowhere or just a bad day when you need someone to talk to, they’re there. Even if it means going out of their way, they make sure you’re never alone when you’re in a bind.

They manage to do this without being too obvious or making a big show of it. They’re subtly showing their love and commitment to you while keeping their cool.

If they’re consistently there for you in times of need, it’s a strong sign they’re in love with you.

7) Their actions speak louder than words

At the end of the day, the most telling sign that someone is deeply in love with you but trying to play it cool is their actions.

Words can be deceiving, and sometimes, people aren’t ready to express their feelings verbally. But their actions seldom lie.

Do they make you feel special? Do they go out of their way to make your life easier or happier? Do they show you respect and kindness consistently?

These actions are the most authentic expressions of their love. If they’re doing all these things while trying to maintain a cool exterior, it’s a surefire sign they’re in love with you.

Final thoughts

Understanding the intricacies of human emotions, especially love, can be a complex endeavor. Love is rarely straightforward and can often be cloaked in subtlety and nuance.

While the signs outlined in this article can provide some insight, every individual expresses love differently. Some might wear their hearts on their sleeves, while others, as we’ve discussed, might play it cool.

The Greek philosopher Plato once said, “At the touch of love everyone becomes a poet.”

This quote beautifully captures the transformative power of love. Love does not only inspire grand gestures but also subtle acts of kindness and care that often go unnoticed.

If you find someone consistently showing you these subtle signs of love, cherish them. It’s these quiet acts of affection that lay the foundation for a deep and meaningful bond.

In the end, love isn’t about grand declarations or extravagant displays. It’s about the small moments, the shared laughter, the comforting silence, and the subtle signs that show someone truly cares for you.