If someone is lying to you, they’ll usually display these 10 subtle behaviors

We sometimes include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Read our affiliate disclosure.

We all like to believe that we’re pretty good at detecting when someone is pulling the wool over our eyes. But, truth be told, it’s not always that simple.

Liars have a knack for disguising their dishonesty behind well-constructed stories and convincing alibis.

Yet, no matter how skilled a fibber might be, there are usually subtle signs that give them away. These tell-tale behaviors are often overlooked but can be incredibly revealing.

In this article, we’ll be delving into the top 10 subtle signs that someone might be lying to you. Keep reading, and you might just become a human lie detector!

1) Inconsistent body language

Communication is not just about words. Our bodies often reveal what we’re not willing to say, or in some cases, what we’re trying to hide.

Liars often struggle to make their body language match their words. They might be spinning a convincing tale, but their physical cues can tell a different story.

For example, they might avoid eye contact, fidget excessively, or display closed-off body language such as crossing their arms or legs. It’s also common for liars to subconsciously touch their face or throat when they are not being truthful, as if trying to cover up the lie.

So next time you’re questioning someone’s honesty, pay close attention to their non-verbal cues. It might reveal more than their words do.

Of course, different people have different baseline behaviors, and it’s essential to understand someone’s usual body language before jumping to conclusions. However, a noticeable change in physical demeanor can be a strong indicator that something is amiss. It might be time to ask some probing questions or observe more closely.

2) Overly detailed stories

Contrary to what you might think, people who lie often do not keep their stories simple. Instead, they tend to give overly detailed accounts in an attempt to make their lies seem more believable.

When someone is being honest, they typically tell their story in a straightforward manner, focusing on the main points. However, when someone starts to provide an excessive amount of unnecessary details, it could be a sign that they’re trying to overcompensate for a lack of truth.

There was this one time when a friend was late to our dinner plans. Instead of a simple explanation, he spun an elaborate tale about a flat tire, a missing jack, and an unusually long wait for roadside assistance. He even described the mechanic’s odd tattoos and how he had to help him lift the car.

In retrospect, it was clear that he was trying too hard to convince me. His overly detailed story was a desperate attempt to make his lies seem more convincing

While it’s certainly possible for a person to be naturally verbose, an unexpected surge of detail in someone’s narrative might be cause for skepticism.

Keep an ear out for this potential red flag when you’re assessing the honesty of the information you’re being given. If people give more information than required, it could be a sign that they’re trying to cover up a lie with a web of deception.

3) Change in tone

When people lie, their stress levels often rise, which can cause physical changes. One of these changes can be in their voice.

A person’s vocal pitch tends to rise when they’re being dishonest. The strain of maintaining a lie can introduce a tension in our voices that sharp-eared listeners can pick up on. 

This is because lying triggers the body’s “fight or flight” response, leading to an increased heart rate and tightened vocal cords. The result is a voice that sounds higher than usual. It’s a raw and human reaction to an uncomfortable situation.

So, if you notice a change in someone’s voice that suddenly becomes unnaturally high-pitched, they could potentially be weaving a tale. Combine this with other signs, and you may have a clearer picture of their honesty.

4) Avoiding direct answers

One of the most common signs of a liar is their knack for dodging direct answers. Instead of responding clearly and concisely, they may beat around the bush, deflect the question, or even respond with another question.

For instance, if you ask someone if they took your missing item and they respond with “Why would I take it?” instead of a simple “no,” it could be a red flag.

Liars often use this tactic to buy themselves time to craft their narrative or to shift the focus away from their dishonesty. So, if someone seems to be avoiding giving straight answers, it might be worth probing a little further.

5) Repeating questions before answering

When someone repeats a question you’ve asked before answering it, it might not just be because they didn’t hear you clearly. This could be a subtle sign that they’re stalling to think of a believable lie.

For example, if you ask “Did you finish the project?” and they respond with “Did I finish the project? Well…” and then proceed with their answer, it could be a sign of dishonesty.

This repetition gives them extra time to formulate their response and weave their tale. So keep an ear out for unnecessary question repetition – it might be an indication of deception.

6) Verbal stumbles

When we speak truthfully, our words usually flow smoothly since we’re simply recounting our genuine experiences or thoughts. However, people who are fabricating stories might stumble over their words more frequently.

An interesting aspect of human psychology is that lying requires more mental effort than telling the truth. We have to create a believable story, keep track of the details, and ensure our facial expressions and body language don’t give us away. This additional mental load can lead to verbal stumbles such as stuttering, repetition, or longer-than-usual pauses.

While everyone trips over their words occasionally, an increase in these verbal missteps during a conversation could be a sign that someone is not being completely honest with you.

7) Defensive reactions

A common human reaction when we feel accused or cornered is to become defensive. This behavior often intensifies when a person is not telling the truth.

Have you ever asked someone a simple question, only to have them respond aggressively or with an unexpected level of defensiveness? This could be a significant indicator that they’re hiding something.

I remember a time when I confronted a colleague about why he hadn’t completed his part of a team project. Instead of admitting his mistake or providing a reasonable explanation, he immediately became defensive. He accused me of blaming him unnecessarily and turned the situation around to make it seem like I was the one in the wrong. His overly defensive behavior was a clear sign that he wasn’t being truthful.

Of course, it’s essential to consider the context and the nature of your relationship with the person. Some people are naturally defensive, while others could be having a bad day. But if this reaction is out of character or disproportionate to the situation, it might be time to dig a little deeper.

8) Contradictory statements

When we tell the truth, our stories naturally align because we’re recounting actual events or genuine thoughts. 

Liars often have to remember the details of their fabricated stories, and sometimes, they slip up. They might make contradictory statements or change their story when asked to recount it.

They might tell you one thing, then later, perhaps forgetting their initial lie, say something that completely contradicts their previous statement.

For instance, a person might initially claim they were at a certain place at a specific time, but later say something that is completely different. Such inconsistencies can be a clear giveaway of dishonesty. 

This is one of the most telling signs of a lie. If you notice these inconsistencies in someone’s narrative, it’s likely that they’re not being entirely truthful. So, when you’re trying to ascertain the truth, listen carefully for any contradictions in their story.

9) Frequent affirmations of honesty

Sometimes, the more a person insists they’re telling the truth, the less likely they are to be doing so.

It might seem paradoxical, but individuals who are being dishonest often feel the need to repeatedly affirm their honesty. Phrases like “to be honest,” “trust me,” or “I swear” start peppering their conversation.

While these expressions are common in everyday language, an increase in their usage might be a subconscious attempt to convince you (and themselves) of their honesty.

Next time you’re engaged in a conversation, pay attention to how often these phrases are used. It might reveal more than the speaker intends.

10) Trust your gut

Ultimately, one of the most reliable indicators of someone’s honesty might just be your own intuition. We often have a gut feeling when something isn’t quite right.

It could be a combination of all these subtle signs or even something else entirely. But if you feel uneasy or doubtful about someone’s words, don’t dismiss it.

Your gut instinct is a powerful tool, and it’s worth paying attention to when assessing someone’s truthfulness. After all, our instincts have been honed over thousands of years for survival – and they can be remarkably accurate in detecting deception.

Summing up: It’s all about observation

Understanding human behavior, especially when it comes to deceit, is a complex task. It’s a cocktail of conscious and subconscious cues, verbal and non-verbal communication, and an array of emotions.

These subtle signs we’ve discussed – from inconsistencies in body language to unanswered questions and defensive behaviors – are just potential signals. They aren’t foolproof indicators of dishonesty. After all, people are unique, with their own quirks and habits.

Yet, these signals can serve as valuable tools in our quest for truth. They remind us to pay attention, to listen carefully, and to observe thoughtfully.

In the end, detecting a lie has less to do with uncovering deception and more to do with truly understanding the people around us. It’s about fostering genuine connections built on trust and transparency.

So as you navigate your relationships, keep these signs in mind. Not as a lie detector test, but as a reminder to stay observant and empathetic. Because at the heart of it all, we’re just trying to understand each other better. And that’s a pursuit worth investing in.

Isabella Chase

Isabella Chase, a New York City native, writes about the complexities of modern life and relationships. Her articles draw from her experiences navigating the vibrant and diverse social landscape of the city. Isabella’s insights are about finding harmony in the chaos and building strong, authentic connections in a fast-paced world.

If a woman uses these phrases in a conversation, she’s trying to impress you

7 signs you didn’t receive enough affection as a child